American Home Shield

Name: American Home Shield
Rating: 4.0

4.0

star star star star star_border

19,877 User Reviews

6.8

Overall Score

Visit Site

4.0

star star star star star_border

19,877 User Reviews

6.8

Overall Score

Visit Site

Pros

Cons

Bottom Line

Reviews

Write a Review

Company Details

Number of Plans

Service Fee

Starting at

$75

Contract Options Available

Annual

Home Inspection Required

Time in Business

55 Years

Company Headquarters

150 Peabody Place, Suite 300 Memphis, TN 38103

Number of Reviews 19,877

info Source of Information

Author: Kalicia Bateman

LAST UPDATED: January 18th, 2023

American Home Shield® is the founder of the home warranty industry and is one of the market leaders with over 1.7 million customers. Beginning in 1971, the company's goal has always been to protect homeowners from high, unexpected home repair costs. American Home Shield is affiliated with the home service company Frontdoor.

With its extensive experience in the home warranty business, American Home Shield is a trusted name compared to other service providers in the industry. American Home Shield offers a variety of warranty plans, including a build-your-own plan that allows customers to select the individual systems and appliances they'd like coverage for.

Read American Home Shield reviews below as well as the pros and cons of the company.

thumb_up

Pros

Time in Business
Discount Programs
Three Flexible Plans
Electronics Plan
Multiple Fee Options
Upfront Contract Information
No Home Inspection
Discounted Air Filters
Sample Service Contract
American Home Shield Reviews

Time in Business

American Home Shield has more than 45 years of experience and became the industry founder when it created home warranties back in 1971. American Home Shield now has more than 1.7 million customers and is one of the largest warranty companies in the industry. Being in business for so long is a good indicator that American Home Shield is equipped to give its customers what they want in a home warranty company.

Discount Programs

In addition to its decades of home warranty experience, American Home Shield offers its customers many money-saving incentives, including its Appliance Discount Program. With this discount program, customers save money over MSRP and have Energy Star certified options. Customers can also benefit from American Home Shield's "Refer a Friend" program, which rewards customers with a $25 Amazon gift card for each friend referred. In addition, the company offers discounts on air filters.

Three Flexible Plans

American Home Shield offers a home systems plan, appliances plan, and a combo plan — these plans are known as the following: ShieldSilver™, ShieldGold™, and ShieldPlatinum™. A detailed of what each plan covers is as follows:

ShieldSilver™ Plan
Covers 14 major home systems:

Air conditioner
Heating units
Ductwork
Exhaust, vent, and attic fans
Breaker and fuse panel box
Doorbell and chimes
Interior electrical system
Ceiling fans
Garage door openers
Interior plumbing system
Toilets
Faucets and valves
Whirlpool tub motor and components
Water heaters

ShieldGold™ Plan
Covers all the systems included in the ShieldSilver™ Plan, as well as the following appliances:

Refrigerators
Ranges/cooktops
Ovens
Dishwashers
Built-in microwaves
Garbage disposal
Instant hot/cold water dispensers
WashersDryers

ShieldPlatinum™ Plan
Covers all systems included in the ShieldSilver™ and ShieldGold™ plans, as well as the following roof leak coverage:

Shingles, tiles, and shakes
Flat, non-metal roofing
Flashing
Underlayment

These plans will cover the majority of homeowner needs, but American Home Shield offers add-on coverage for household electronics, as well as pools and spas.

Electronics Plan

A unique coverage option provided by American Home Shield, offered by Allstate Protection Plans, is its electronics coverage plan, protecting any electronics in your home. Any new products that your purchase will be automatically covered, if eligible. Some eligible products include the following:

TVs
Home theater systems
Desktop/laptops
Tablets
Printers
Smart Home products
Headphones
Video game consoles (including controllers)

Electronics will be covered for mechanical and electrical failures due to normal wear and tear, as well as unprecedented events, such as a power surge.

Real Estate Plans

American Home Shield provides flexible coverage options for home buyers and sellers, allowing you to shop or sell confidently. The company provides the following plans:

ShieldEssential℠
Covers major home systems:

Heating and cooling
Electrical
Plumbing
Rekey service

ShieldPlus℠
Covers all systems included in the ShieldEssential℠, as well as the following major appliances:

Kitchen appliances
Laundry appliances

ShieldComplete℠
Covers all systems included in the ShieldEssential℠ and ShieldPlus℠ plans, as well as some added services:

Roof leak repair
One free rekey with no service fee
Unlimited refrigerant
Coverage for code violations, permits, and modifications

Each plan is backed by a 30-day workmanship guarantee and each includes special member offers. Real estate agents have the added benefit of the American Home Shield Partner Portal to easily track and manage client home warranty plans.

Multiple Fee Options

With American Home Shield, customers pay a trade service call fee for a professional to help them with their problem, then fix the system or appliance or replace it. The three options for this service fee are $75, $100, and $125, which gives customers flexibility in how much they pay each month for their plan coverage. The higher the trade service call fee, the lower the amount the customer will pay each month.

Upfront Contract Information

American Home Shield offers a sample contract on its website, making it easy for customers to get an idea of what the company offers. American Home Shield also states upfront that the company does not require a home inspection in order to purchase a warranty plan and will not limit coverage based on the age of any of your home systems or appliances, making it easier for customers to get warranty coverage.

This upfront contract information helps the customer decide early on if American Home Shield is a home warranty company that will work for their needs.

No Home Inspection

Unlike some home warranty providers, American Home Shield does not require a home inspection or maintenance records before using its services. The company also does not decline coverage based on the age of your systems and appliances. This is convenient for customers who want a simple home warranty process and don't want to worry about a home inspection process to discover what systems and appliances are covered and what ones aren't.

Discounted Air Filters

As part of your AHS customer perks, you can get up to 50 percent off retail prices on air conditioning and furnace filters. American Home Shield will also deliver the filters directly to your home. However, it is unclear whether or not you have to pay extra for delivery, so check with the company to be sure.

Sample Service Contract

American Home Shield has a sample contract available online. According to our research, a majority of 1-star reviews for the home warranty industry involve claim denials that are typically outlined in the contract, such as damage that is beyond the scope of normal wear and tear, damages covered by another warranty such as a manufacturer's warranty, and damages from not following building codes.

American Home Shield ensures that you can see the terms outlined in a sample contract and be aware of the offered coverage.

American Home Shield Reviews

Of the 19,000+ American Home Shield customer reviews on BestCompany.com, 71 percent of reviews are 4 or 5 stars. Satisfied customers frequently highlight the following from their experience with the company:

Timely responses and repairs
Extensive coverage for all home systems and appliances under on warranty
Amiable and knowledgable customer service representatives

Visit Site

thumb_down

Cons

Customer Complaints
Lack of Monthly Pricing Information

Customer Complaints

Common customer complaints for American Home Shield range from rising warranty prices to bad customer service processes. There have also been complaints regarding the company's network of service technicians handling repairs, with some customers waiting days for a local technician only to have multiple faulty repairs. You can read American Home Shield reviews below to find out what else customers have to say about how they think American Home Shield warranty compares to other service providers.

Lack of Monthly Pricing Information

American Home Shield does not provide any information about monthly pricing on its website. Interested consumers are encouraged to obtain a quote from the company for more information on pricing.

gavel

The Bottom Line

There is a lot of good to say about American Home Shield. The company has extensive experience in the home warranty industry and offers discount programs, extensive coverage of many home appliances and systems, and options when it comes to trade service call fees. Its plan customization makes it simple for customers to find the right home warranty for their needs.

Being the founder of the home warranty industry, American Home Shield has extensive experience to back up its name. Many warranty companies are not as experienced as AHS, and this may result in quality issues.

If you're interested in learning more about the American Home Shield warranty experience, such as customer service and claim response time, check out American Home Shield reviews below. The company may be the right provider for you to protect your home's systems and appliances against regular wear and tear and other common malfunctions.

Was this content helpful?

thumb_up Yes thumb_down No

border_color Write a Review

User Reviews

Star Rating

4.0

star star star star star_border

19,877 Reviews

Review Breakdown

5 grade

59%

4 grade

12%

3 grade

2 grade

1 grade

15%

Sentiment Criteria

Value

star star star star_half star_border

Quality

star star star star star_border

Service

star star star star_half star_border

Trustworthiness

star star star star_half star_border

cancel

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

J Bingham

I've had to use my home warranty more this year than before. My dishwasher went out, although it took a few months to figure out the issue and 2 different contractors, I ultimately got a new one after the problem was figured out. Next, my washing machine started having issues. There was a possibility to fix it with some delay in parts for the supply chain issues. Rather than make us wait to fix the problem, American Home Shield offered us the cost of repair so we could get a new washing machine. I took that option and had a new washing machine delivered the following week. I had to send in copies of my receipts to AHS and they sent the checks to me right away. This is a true review and other than being a satisfied customer and AHS resolving my issues, I haven't been paid to write this.

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Denise Fuller Upper Marlboro, MD

I always request my service online, and immediately I get a notice my request has been assigned, and minutes after that request, the servicing company calls to set up a date to come out. In the past when I would call for service, I could never get through. My last request last month, the service man kept me informed of his arrival status. He was very professional, polite, and knowledgeable. My furnace was good, and he could not find any issues. But the next cold day the furnace was doing the same issue. I believe the issue is the thermostat, because it would continue to run for 3 mins, off 2 minutes, and this goes on all day. But at night the heat comes on and goes off frequently, then sometime during the night, we would be freezing, in house temp would be at 67, temp set at 71 or 72. When i turned it up to 74, it would stay at 74 in house temp, but still frequently cut on and off. Furnace ok, per serviceman, that's why I feel it's the thermostat. I feel I paid my $100, and got no fix to my issue. All in all, the 6 years I've been wit AHS, has been great service, but I've only used the service 3 or 4 times in my 6 years. Thank you for your service.

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Janis Elliott Lubbock, TX

When I have a problem (most often plumbing), I have to phone, otherwise you assign me the worst plumbers on the planet. The last time I called I got through very quickly to the best customer representative I've ever encountered at AHS. Here name is Andrea and she was so helpful and everything went smoothly that day. I was assigned the plumber of my choice and they were able to show up within a couple of hours. The planets aligned, thanks to Andrea. Out of habit, I hung up, forgetting to the survey right away. Please put this on Andrea's record that she made my day!!! She is the reason for the 4th star instead of only 3 stars.

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Ken Plano, TX

Terrible communications, automated phone system designed to frustrate to the point you give up. Went on line, when I renewed they failed to update and the system kept showing my account expired. Again no phone service to get help until I finally punched in the number to purchase new plan. Suddenly I am connected to sales with an agent anxious to sell. Told my story, she was frustrated and told me I needed customer service. Finally convinced her to connect me. Still I gave 4 stars because once I could file the claim I had a contractor assigned within an hour. He was at my home next day snd resolved the issue within minutes. So it works if you can ever get pass the blockage.

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

George Nonomura Nevada City, CA

For the first time AHS warranty failed me. I have a dishwasher that isn't draining. One tech replaced the pump and it drained fine. As soon as he left the drain stopped draining again. I did as he suggested and I removed the strainer. It drained faster than the sink drain could flow. The water filled to the top of the sink drain. Then it stopped again. This time I reached down into the washer drain under the strainer. I found a cherry pit. As the second tech was coming he asked if I knew what the problem was. I said I found a cherry pit. He took my word for that and said the service wouldn't be covered because AHS didn't cover clogged dishwashers. He should have come out to see if i was right. It was my best guess but I'm no service tech. AHS also should have called me to say that a clogged drain isn't covered. I went on his word that AHS doesn't cover this.

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

ZZMARR LAFETT STONE Moreno Valley, CA

Probably no fault of home shield but the service person takes a week to show up to my house and then misdiagnose the issue I was having so when he finished his service I was left with still having a leak to solve. But the service man did tell me that our washing machine was not leaking he pointed out the problem to be the drain. So I routed and serviced the drainage. Next time we used the washer and dryer there was yet still a leak. I ofcourse called home shield again and upon my complaint they refunded the service call and rescheduled another service, days went by and by, and sense we could clearly see it was the dryer that was leaking my wife called the gas company they showed up within an hour he checked the entire house for gas leaks and then fixed the water leak on the dryer. A hose was loose he simply tightened it with a screwdriver and the leak was no more. So the next day when the water was dried up and there was no leak my wife called home shield back again and canceled the service call that we were still waiting for. But story continues because yesterday the bill receipt arrived and shows the one service call refunded and then it shows two more service calls added surely this is something else that I will have to contend with as I sort out the two extra service calls but no one showed up a second, or a third time. Or maybe you could solve this one, I appreciate your response.

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Karen Carpenter Sacramento, CA

I had a refrigerator that was not cold and the food was going bad. They told me they would contact someone to schedule and appointment with 7-10 days. I told them that was crazy as the food was rotting. They got me an appointment for four days later; however, the tech for Prime appliances/Dan just took pictures of the part he thought was needed and AHS would would send them the part within two weeks. Then they would schedule another appointment within the week. The bad part was that he did not do a thorough job/he replaced the ice maker without checking the freezer. Something else was wrong/the whole back panel that has the two fans needed to be replaced. After waiting so long to get this resolved, I then called Prime back and they sent out their lead tech/Kim (great tech) who once again took pictures. At least he removed all the packed ice. It was also not working and needed replacement. That meant I had to go through the whole waiting period again. I was not aware I had been charged an additional $100 for Prime. The way I see it, That second trip should not have been necessary if the first tech had done a thorough job. I jus heard AHS will replace the cost of all my food lost from a friend. Hope that it true. I wanted to say what a great job Kim/3nd tech when he came to complete the job.

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Renee Conyers, GA

4 star rating is due to a negative experience had a few months ago with assigning our technician that was posted online as a 1 star when we repeatedly said no. AHS should not be associated with these companies and sending them out to the customers homes. I reported this information to them and asked why and were they aware of the negative and poor ratings which AHS was highlighted in all the reviews. The customer service representative stated this would be reported to management. Not sure if it was but so far I haven't had that company for any assignments. I was also told I had the highest plan when purchased years ago, but had to come kut of pocket 800.00 for a issue was fully covered. Hopefully AHS will work on gaining a 5 star rating soon. Customer service has been good so far since those two incidents, AHS did upgrade on new packages but too early to rate. So far AHS is moving in the right direction.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Laura Lawhon Butler Conroe, TX

I began my experiences with AHS in Southern California in the 1970's and they were phenomenal through the decades I had them. When we bought this house in Texas the AHS program was part of the sale. I was less than impressed and I switched to two different companies. When AHS contacted me to return to them this past winter I was hesitant. Since the other two companies were not what I'd hoped they'd be, I decided to give AHS one last go. This time, months later, we had a major plumbing problem and AHS sent several companies out to check it. I wasn't trusting them and asked to have my own plumber who instantly knew exactly what we needed. AHS did pay their portion of the negotiated repairs. Not the entire amount but enough for me to be satisfied. For now, so long as they remain as responsive as they've been this year, I will happily stay with them. It is reassuring to know that they actually will cover major repairs. Their prices are competitive as well. One company I was with made us pay out of pocket for a relatively late model water heater, then submit the invoice to them. Their rate of reimbursement was a huge disappointment. It is too bad that AHS now has their customer service department outsourced in a faraway foreign country and it does take some extra time getting them to realize what the issues are if the repair is a complicated one. For the normal everyday repairs this works out just fine. We actually did get to speak with a local representative when we decided to stay with them. It is nice to know that they do exist...you just have to be persistent to get to them if your situations warrants it.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Sandra Sachs Brooksville, FL

I called about a problem I'm having with my laptop. Before I added the electronics coverage, I asked if service was provided in house - I was told Yes. When I called I was told that I would receive a box in 5 days to mail my laptop to them, and that I should remove any login pasword, and backup my computer prior to shipping it since their actions could result in loss of some or all of my data. Since my computer won't boot, none of this was possible. I cancelled my claim and called AHW to express my opinion about this service. After 2 hours on the phone, being transferred from person to person, I was told that I could not file a complaint with AMW about the eletronics warrenty/policy since you didn't service electronics. However, I pay YOU for the electronics coverage, and YOU contract for this service to a 2nd party. If one of you customers has an issue with this 2nd party, YOU should be informed about it.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Amber Francis Walker, LA

Almost all my interactions have been very good. They were easy to pay and fast to get someone out. Had difficulty with two but were both resolved in the end. I was out of a fridge for over two months which is a little absurd considering it was the first repair company that damaged my fridge beyond repair when it needed an easy fix. Then the amount I was reimbursed was not enough to get one of equal so I had to apply for a Lowe’s credit card to pay the $484 difference. And I got a very off brand, nothing as good as my kenmore, and I’ve already had two problems with the 8 month old fridge. Having a family of six living out of ice chests for that long is unacceptable. Especially during school months for my kids’ meals and snacks. That was the worst out of six. The other five were top notch though. Would still, and do recommend, but suggest the company do some follow up on the maintenance contractors in instances like this that kind of screw the homeowner. I loved my fridge and it was top of the line. Now I had to come out of pocket over $500 and have bottom of the line.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Verna Snyder Tacoma, WA

I have only used American Home Shield once in the 3 years I have had it. The service was very quick. There are two thing I would suggest that would make using a home warranty more worth wile. First the company used for appliance repairs, has their employees use their own phones to contact customers and for older customers, if they don’t recognize a phone number, they many times block it. The other suggestion I would make is that American Home Shield should offer an insentive for customers who don’t use their American Home Shield by offering some sort of service if account is not used regularly.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Debra Hollingsworth Pittsburgh, PA

This year good...last year 2020 stressful coverage for plumber..when I called in to your customer service I was told that my outdoor water turn o /off valve up against house was covered..Ht eplu.ber assigned but whe they got to house I was told it was not covered by home warranty and had to pay 300$.I was very upset and when I called home warranty back had to go through several people..could not get supervisor and the representatives were difficult to understand and I had to repeat situation several ti.es. Was given some addresses but I was sooo stressed from this and couldnt deal with you people. So I lost out of 300$ because your representing gave me false information

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Suzie Carroll Discovery Bay, CA

I have been very pleased with customer service. The only problem we have run into is getting an air conditioning unit in the summertime, but I‚Äôm sure it‚Äôs very difficult for everyone. It‚Äôs taking a long time to get all the approval, my family has been without air conditioning for one month. That we finally got the ball rolling and hopefully will have a new unit soon! The only other experience is a leaky faucet. The service call was very quick, Ordering a faucet took about a week and then about another few days to get it installed. Overall I‚Äôm very pleased, just wish that the air conditioning unit did not take so long to get approved and installed.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Tom Flynn Fishers, IN

Service has improved greatly over the last 4 years. When began with AHS, a hold to speak to someone was typically over 45 minutes. Contractors have been very good. Only have had about 3-4 calls per year but much improved. The last 2 years, the premiums have increased greatly. I have called to speak to a rep about it. Last year, they offered a $125 discount after calling. They then charged entire amount on credit card. Had to call and plead to honor the verbal amount they agreed to. After 2 weeks, they credited my credit card. This year, exactly the same situation. I called. Offered $75 discount on premium. They then charged entire amount to credit card. Had to call back and plead again to honor the verbal amount agree upon. Hence, two years in a row the phone reps didn't charge what agreed upon.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Teresa Powell Hanford, CA

Majority of the time AHS did fine however, the extended time of replacing my dishwasher was totally different. It took from 4/17/21 THRU to 6/25/21 to get it replaced. Records will show I called AHS DAILY . Customer Service was horrible . They would tell me to wait until the process was completed . I was told the authorization dept. had the request and they couldn't help me. Some said.they would call me back but never did. That was an awful time.Now, not everyonee in the customer service was terrible. The last one I talked To did all the work and got the authorization. I'm in my middle 70;s and was very upset because no one wanted to help me.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Larry Wyatt Nashville, TN

Their coverage in writing; is a very decent policy. And we have had two issues. And they will make it right in the end. But in some cases the response time that it takes to set up repair appointments, clearing the approval for said repairs through American home shield, and then making the necessary rescheduled repairs can be a bit more slow than you can afford to be down on the particular appliance. A home air conditioned system is one said such appliance. Their needs to be a faster way to streamline the process of repair or replace. All else being said; they have been very decent people to work with.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Dustin Spencer Peoria, IL

Well, we have had good luck with them fixing things. My problem was this time when we signed up the person didn't go over the coverages well. First never told me about the electronics coverage. I saw that on an advertisement. Called to add it, complete hassle to add it. Second, never told me about using their people for general maintenance on our HVAC and I get one free inspection tune up a year. Called the person that was listed on the furnace of our new home. Didn't do it right and had to pay AHS people for a service call and do what the person i called to do. I know AHS contractor fixed the issue but it was covered and i would have used them anyway if I knew. Selling 101 educate your customers and your people providing the services.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Brooke Kemp Arlington, TX

The service companies provided are not always highly qualified. I dealt with a ridiculous AC repair company multiple times that was sent by AHS. Finally I chose to pay extra out of pocket to have a brand new unit installed. Fast forward two years and it stopped working. I'm happy to see AHS is using a new company (they were great) but frustrated that the other company had to go out of business for a new one to be chosen. The previous company had horror story review after review. They completely screwed the install on my new unit- that's what led to the latest repairs being needed. I'm thankful that the new company was able to correct the mistakes and hope it hasn't caused any long term damage. My hope is that AHS finds affordable, but excellent quality repair companies to work with moving forward.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Sharon Ann Solverson Murrieta, CA

I was referred to one pool company that said they no longer work with AHS then I I was referred to upland Pool Supply to help us repair our pool filter. I was waiting for the repairman to show up and left my side gate unlocked. He came in took a couple of pictures of the filter and never communicated with me. I did not hear anything for over a week and I connected them. It took almost 2 weeks for them to get a new lid and gauge for our filter. In the mean time I rented a portable pool pump with filter so our pool would not turn green. The repair went well and the repairman, Christian , also cleaned our pool. He mentioned he had a side business where he cleaned pools. So far impressed by him I hired him and gave him a check covering a month's service for our pool. He showed up about a week later and cleaned out pool and showed up one more time after I called to see if he was coming. He came and left saying he was going to pick some pool supplies to clean our pool. That was it we never heard from him again.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Pamela Ewing Louisville, KY

AHS is awesome but their contractors not so much. Have had great experiences but having one now that's troublesome. Put in for service on my AC on 6-13-21, Fast Response set appt for the 16th, when they came out unit was frozen so after staying around 10 mins, said they would be back when thawed. Have talked to both Fast Response and AHS, next scheduled day is now 6-23-21. I feel that is horrible service. Should have been on the service schedule for the next day. It is now in the 90's and i have fans trying to keep cool. Thankful I am a patient person. Again satified with AHS just not with Fast Response some. put in for service on my AC

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

AFC Laurel, MD

I was tempted to rate three because of an unresolved issue which I've experienced for first time and in all my 25 years with them, but will rate four. I hope it has nothing to do with the Reps who are usually nice. Also because of their introduction of yearly contract number change which prevents you from having past and present access to your account. There is one customer number in every company I'm associated with so why do we have to have new contracts number every year? I've been unable to get into my online account. And I guess I've lost my history with this company. New policy is very disappointing.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Eric Wilson Sharon, PA

I have mostly had good experiences using my home warranty. It depends on who is available in the area to fix a particular issue, but the the home warranty people took my feedback to heart and now always send my preferred repair company whenever I have an issue. I have had repairs on my refrigerator, oven, and built-in microwave/speed oven -- most of which are over 10 years old, so some issues are expected. I'm not sure what the actual cost of the repairs would have been without the warranty, so I'm not sure whether I am actually getting a good value, but it's nice not to have to worry about a major appliance needing to be replaced unexpectedly.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Brenda Reddick Ludowici, GA

I have been with American Home Shield for 3 years now, and have only used the warranty about 3 times; however, they are very expedient in processing service requests and assigning service providers. However, I think the annual contract price is a little steep. I have compared American Home Shield's price to other warranty company prices and the other companies provided the same or almost the same services, but the cost is much cheaper. I believe that when they are increasing warranty cost, they should only do it for new customers, not for existing customers. Despite that, I will still remain with American Home Shield, because they do come through.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Judy kaye Schwer Las Vegas, NV

I have used AMERICAN SHIELD two times after buying a townhouse. My rating depends on individual technicians that come to assess the problem. The first technician repaired the refrigerator no problem. The second technician was called for a garbage disposal. The blades were making a horrific noise and he saw some white paint on the black rubber insert and immediately said that there was paint in the garbage disposal that was keeping it from working and wasn’t covered. I had someone else come out and look at it and they actually took the garbage disposal out and it was all rusted on the inside… No paint. The first technician didn’t bother to unhook it or look inside.

5 years ago

Reply from American Home Shield

Thank you for sharing your recent experiences with us. We are working diligently to improve the overall member experience and we look forward to our continued business together. Have a great day.

Apr. 5th, 2021

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

James

I love my AHS policy. The only thing that keeps AHS from being perfect is that the process of getting a repair done usually follows a particular pattern: the service person comes out and diagnoses the problem, then says they will check in with AHS before they will schedule the repair or order the part or whatever. Then there will be like a week, sometimes two, sometimes three, when nothing happens. Eventually, I will get a note from AHS asking me to review the service I received, usually before the repair has been completed. Then I will call AHS to get an update on the repair, and find out that some technicality kept the repair from being completed. A little back and forth with AHS will ensue, and then I will receive a call from the service company and the repair will be scheduled and completed. This is literally the same process I have gone through with AHS on nearly every repair for 20 years. I'm usually very happy with the service when it's all done, and I'm always grateful that I have an AHS policy. Nowadays, I just remind myself that it's going to be a process before I engage with AHS on a repair, and that helps me to be patient.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Mike

In general I have had no problems with AHS. I understand that they tend to use lower 'quality' providers since they are the ones likely to be willing to accept lower reimbrsements, but I have had only a few instances where I did not want to use their provider or did not like them. I recently found a provider that wanted to charge me more for a job than a second-opinion I obtained, and I went with the second opinion. But, to their credit, AHS did pay me what they would have given their provider for the job. Basically they only pay about $500 for under slab access and they paid me that and I used my own contractor. I've been with AHS for 18 years and have overall been satisfied, as well as saved money.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Anonomous

Overall they cover the basics but their companies may not be as quick in finalizing the fix as a homeowner would like. I literally had a AC issue with prior issues of slow leak of refrigerant that caused issues. The truck shows up after 3 to 4 days of scheduling time with no refrigerant to refill the AC with. They we waited another 3 to 4 days for them to return. Overall, we were about 3 weeks without AC during the summer months. It just seemed not appropriate and finally got tired of paying for the refrigerant cost when they could not find the leak and at our cost replaced the AC. Not real happy about how it all was handled and their policy of only providing 10 pounds of refrigerant where we paid the rest and the situation kept happening. Because it was now working they provided no support on the replacement.

6 years ago

Reply from American Home Shield

Hi,

We really appreciate you taking the time to share your rating with us. We look forward to servicing you again soon.

Jul. 28th, 2020

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Palmira Pacheco San Antonio, TX

The only time that we did get good service was with the air condition Service companies. We have had Home Shield since we build our home and we did have any problems until our unit went out and a coil was to be replaced. But what really happened was that all the inside unit was replace, but we were not told and it was a Pane, Not a Trane. All the wires were cut and it took several times to call before an experienced person came and got the unit to work. When the unit went out again, we were told what was wrong, but our maintaintence company had come the day before, we call them Back and they found an other problem. We had them fix it and it worked well again. When it was time to purchase a new unit, we did nit call Home Shield, we had our Maintence Co. do the work.

6 years ago

Reply from American Home Shield

Hi Pamira,
Thank you for providing us with insight on your experience to have the air conditioner repaired.

Jun. 7th, 2020

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Dominique Maddux-Jackson

I think the service was great and they were really quick and helpful. The only downside was I have a tankless water heater. The first company that was dispatched to help, does not work on tankless water heaters. So, I then had to wait until a second company was able to come out, so us not being able to stay in our home was extended by a day or two. I think that if having a tankless water heater makes a difference, customer service reps should ask that before determining what company to reach out to for the client. That way everyone is saved some time. The customers, like myself, may not know that this make a difference and that not everyone works on tankless water hearters. Otherwise, everything was great and every one was super friendly and helpful!

6 years ago

Reply from American Home Shield

Hi Dominique,
We are thrilled to have you as part of the AHS family! Thank you for sharing your kind words with us. It means the world to us and to our entire team! We look forward to serving you again soon!

Mar. 23rd, 2020

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Sheila A Cutchlow Inglewood, CA

They were good to work with and did indeed stand by their word. I had to replace a furnace AND a water heater within a 6 week period! Yikes. I wish they had a system that they retained EXACTLY what units they agreed to cover. The rep said he didn't know and since I am a remote landlord, it made it a bit challenging to understand quality of the units. The water heater pilot light is already faulty so now there's a bit of a "process" to make sure this is a solid unit, and it's proving a bit taxing for the contractor because of the repeated visits.

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Denise Hoffstead Orlando, FL

I love AHS, but my last experience was not the best in the beginning, because of the company they had the contract with. I asked for the companies master tech, they sent him out & he is amazing, he actually cared to solve to problem & I appreciate that. So AHS is actually redeeming my confidence back into their company. I will continue to do business with them in the future.

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Charles F White Owings, MD

The first ticket I opened was did not have the correct information. The first HVAC company couldn't make the repairs. The temperature dropped and the ticket was not considered an expedite. A second HVAC company was dispatched and diagnosed the problem and was resolved satisfactory. AHS did a good job with the majority of this issue with the exception of time it took to resolve considering the temperature.

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Norma Priscilla Chavez Austin, TX

I have been an AHS member for many years and utilized their contractors numerous times. My biggest problem is the service fee of $75. Everytime I have a service call, I am charged twice for the service fee. This must be fixed. For the most part contractors are competent, however I did have an experience of a very incompetent plumber. He was not a plumber. Send the pro's out first please.

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Victor A. Donayre Norcross, GA

I have a older house, and I experienced many water leaks, and HSA always was able to assist me. Sometimes, the companies that were contacted to check or fix my house issues weren't able to go sooner. Also, I pay for appliances coverage. One time, my LG washer quit working and after calling HSA, they sent a company that later on told me HSA didn't approve the repair.. To me, I doesn't make sense why I should pay for a service that HSA won't provide.

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Carole Taylor Lufkin, TX

I have had a contract with AHS for nine years. Service had always been excellent until my claim for a gas furnace filed in November 2021. I have talked with your service reps. It took until mid-December to get my furnace replaced. It was a frustrating experience . The techncian could not get a furnace. You can review the records. Even though this was not good overall AHS has been very responsive in the past.

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Alissa May Ten Mile, TN

I sent in a repair for my refrigerator on 11/16 the parts for were not able to be found so I received an email 12/10 saying we were getting a new refrigerator and I would receive an email with options within 48 hours now it has been 2 weeks I have called and got the run around with no answers.. plus another experience with our heat and air unit as well

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Mike Reno, NV

As with any business, your experience is directly related to who you deal with. At first, their representative ignore my concerns and problems with their service technician. I was so mad that I called back to cancel my policy with AHS. The person who took that call was sympathetic to me not having heat in my home and scheduled a different company to look at my furnace. That second technician was excellent. So, in the end AHS redeemed themselves. But the reason they don't get a 5 star from me is because I shouldn't have had to go to that extent to get help.

4 years ago

Reply from American Home Shield

Hi Mike. Thank you so much for providing feedback of your service experience. We are very happy to know you reached someone who was able to work with you and resolve the issue. We look forward to providing you with a better experience in the future.

Dec. 22nd, 2021

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Charles Crawford Oklahoma City, OK

I believe that this company has gone a long way from the start. I have been with them from almost the beginning and their coverage is really good and price is right but still some flaws when it comes to the re-placement of warranty items as far as we're it ends and begins for example they delay in replacement and it takes a very long process to get resolved such as air units motors wires etc. I think if it doesn't fix the problems then there should be no questions! I give them 4 stars because they could improve in this area but overall worth what you pay in the long hall!

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Beth Prosper, TX

It's been good until recently. I had an electrical problem that took about four days without hearing from them contacted you folks two different times finally after your not be able to contact them yours given to another electrician. The electrician did come out and work on our problem. Our problem is back and now I'm trying to wait another week to get our problem fixed.

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Mary Hadley Canoga Park, CA

I love the convenience and assistance. However, had a bad experience with a horrible plumber, who didn't even do proper diagnosis of our issue and left our property saying we need a new mainline. Now, I continue to receive mail from "Front Door" telling me MY request for a new mainline isn't covered by ASH. I NEVER asked for this, and I don't need a new mainline. Plumber was an incompentent lazy dude that didn't want to work and just walked off after not even being here for 2 minutes.

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Ms. Lawson Atlanta, GA

At times it takes a little longer to receive parts. Next I do not like the hold time when wanting to speak with a live person on the phone. Finally I have had to wait for months for them to fix or replace a hot water tank. They replaced most of all the broken parts on the water tank which took months until they couldn't find a part after that they finally replaced it. I felt that after they paid for all the parts and paid for the time they probably could have bought about 2 hot water tanks and I would have had hot water for those 2 months.

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Suzanne Lane Dixon, CA

I haven't called for an actual repair yet. Not sure what to expect. Technician was nice guy and said everything looked ok. No repairs were made and filters weren't dirty. But he said something could go wrong at anytime so I guess there is no such thing as "preventative maintenance" I have a different kind of filter that is electro magnetic he had not seen before. But I guess all was good.

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Donna Bierd Keller, TX

I like that I have a company that I can go to when I have a repair. But, you do not get a #1 rated company to come out to repair your problem. Second they never have the necessary parts available to fix your problem and then it takes days or weeks to fix your problem. When you're dealing with a refrigerator or washing machine that is really bad because this something you need to use every day.

4 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Adam Metcalf Bremerton, WA

I have had truly wonderful experiences with AHS and the response time that the company has. Sometimes though it is the contractors that they refer out that are an issue. When that is the case AHS is always professional and courteous to get those issues resolved as best they can. Sometimes though resolution isn't possible and that is why I can't give a perfect score.

4 years ago

Reply from American Home Shield

Hi Adam,
Thank you for providing us with feedback about your AHS experience. We strive to provide you with prompt and professional service. We hope you continue to enjoy the coverage we provide!

Oct. 29th, 2021

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

LEAH JACKSON Conyers, GA

I think AHS is a good company and, overall, would recommend them. However, I've notice their customer service level has gone down and would rate as a 3-3.5 due the difficulty in reaching a supervisor. Also, it appears they do not have a dedicated response area for direct complaints to upper management and/or the department that approves subcontractors for complaints against said subcontractors.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

C Brooks Glen Carbon, IL

I have had to have a few service calls. Was satisfied with the prompt service. Not pleased with having to place a couple of service calls for my air conditioner n having to pay for the freon both times within a year. $90 the first time n $130 most recently. I don’t understand why the problem couldn’t just be fixed immediately instead of filling it with freon that is just going to leak. So far I’m very pleased with my washing machine service . Have not yet received my reimbursement because I just made the purchase n submitted the receipt to AHS.

5 years ago

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Karen Herron Youngsville, LA

I had no problem until recently when I made the request for a ceiling fan repair/replacement 2hixh was scheduled and no contact.was made from the person selected so I canceled it. I rescheduled the appointment and requested another company but the same company was scheduled who didn't contact me again. So that appointment was canceled. I am now waiting for my refund for the service fee which was processed even though no service was provided for the ceiling fan.

5 years ago

Reply from American Home Shield

Hi Karen. Thank you for letting us know about yourexperience. I am sorry to hear that your trade service fee was not refunded for the cancelled service request. I would be happy to speak with you to address this issue further.

Sep. 16th, 2021

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Michele Brown Stokesdale, NC

The professional sent to do the job was excellent; however, I was disappointed with the directive of AHS to not do the complete job. We were made responsible for removing a tile and are now responsible for replacing the tile. I have had an experience with another home warranty company for a rental property where they had to remove a tile fir access to the problem snd they provided the professional and covered all the cost related to resolving the problem. Again, to be clear, the professional who did the job was 5 star.

5 years ago

Reply from American Home Shield

Hi Michele. Thank you for taking time to let us know how pleased you were with the vendor who made the repair for your service issue. I understand your concerns regarding the coverage for tile that had to be removed. While there are some limitations on coverage in certain situations we strive to provide the best coverage possible for our members as the leading home warranty company. We look forward to providing you with a better experience for your next repair need.

Aug. 31st, 2021

check_circle

Verified Customer

star star star star star_border

Chip V Silver Spring, MD

My experience with American Home Shield has been 90% positive. They answer the call at all times and are very respectful. During the call they keep up to date at all time. Only issue has was when my fridge was leaking water. the part was on back order and they didn't know when it would be available. So had to insist on getting a resolution because it has been more than 21 days. So it took a while to get to some one with authorization to approve on getting a new fridge because there was no other solution.

5 years ago

Reply from American Home Shield

Hi Chip. Thank you for taking time to let us know about your service experiences. I am happy to hear that you have been pleased with your warranty service for the most part. We appreciate your patience as we worked through the issue regarding your refrigerator. We look forward to taking care of you next repair need with a much better level of service.

Aug. 31st, 2021