We may receive referral compensation from some of the companies on our site. This compensation does not impact their reviews or rankings. Why you can trust us

Write a Review

For Businesses

We may receive referral compensation from some of the companies on our site. This compensation does not impact their reviews or rankings. Why you can trust us

Company Comparison Assistant

Choose two Home Warranty companies to compare or see the Featured Comparisons listed below.

Select Your State

check_circle Not a verified partner

6.0 Overall Score

3.9

star star star star star_border

(3,123)

View Profile

check_circle Not a verified partner

6.8 Overall Score

4.0

star star star star star_border

(19,877)

View Profile

Visit Site

Overview

First American Home Warranty

Number of Plans

Service Fee

Undisclosed

Contract Options Available

Annual

Home Inspection Required

N/A

Time in Business

42 Years

American Home Shield

Number of Plans

Service Fee

$75

Contract Options Available

Annual

Home Inspection Required

Time in Business

55 Years

Ratings

First American Home Warranty

Overall Score

6.0 of 10

Review Score

3.9

star star star star star_border

Value for Money

3.7

star star star star_half star_border

Quality of Product or Service

3.7

star star star star_half star_border

Company Trustworthiness

3.8

star star star star star_border

Likely to Recommend

7.1 of 10

American Home Shield

Overall Score

6.8 of 10

Review Score

4.0

star star star star star_border

Value for Money

3.7

star star star star_half star_border

Quality of Product or Service

3.8

star star star star star_border

Company Trustworthiness

3.7

star star star star_half star_border

Likely to Recommend

7.4 of 10

Pros & Cons

First American Home Warranty

PROS

24/7 claims filing
Customizable plans

CONS

2 plan options
No online sample contract

American Home Shield

PROS

Monthly and annual payment options
Plans for homeowners, realtors, and sellers
Transferrable contracts
30-day workmanship guarantee

CONS

30-day waiting period
Fee and service costs with cancellation

Featured Comparisons

2-10 Home Buyers Warranty vs Choice Home Warranty

View Comparison

First American Home Warranty vs Choice Home Warranty

View Comparison

Fidelity National vs American Home Shield

View Comparison

Sears Home Warranty vs American Home Shield

View Comparison

First American Home Warranty vs American Home Shield

View Comparison

TotalProtect vs American Home Shield

View Comparison

Choice Home Warranty vs American Home Shield

View Comparison

We're on a mission to empower consumers to make the best decisions and connect confidently with companies that deserve their business.