Carvana Logo
star star star_border star_border star_border

3.8

Overall Score

Author: Kaitlyn Short

LAST UPDATED: April 8th, 2022

Carvana is an Arizona-based online-only car sales company with an inventory of 17,700 certified pre-owned cars.

Users browse, shop, and even finance and purchase their car online, without visiting a car dealership. Payment is accepted via checking or savings account ACHs or cashier’s checks. Although this is an online purchase, you can’t pay with a credit card. You also have the option of buying a car with Carvana or third-party financing.

Prices are often below Kelley Blue Book value, and the company offers a hassle-free purchase process with haggle-free price for each vehicle. There are no hidden fees. Each car is shown with an “out-the-door price” transparently displayed for each vehicle listing. This price includes the following:

  • Sticker price
  • Local taxes, title, registration (from your zip code)
  • Any extras, such as extended warranty, gap coverage, and delivery fee

Carvana service areas:

  • Alabama — Birmingham
  • Arizona —Tolleson, Tucson
  • California — Bakersfield, Fresno, Los Angeles, San Diego, San Francisco, San Jose,
  • Sacramento
  • Colorado — Denver
  • Connecticut — Hartford
  • Florida — Jacksonville, Miami, Naples, Orlando, Tampa
  • Georgia — Atlanta, Augusta, Columbus, Macon, Savannah
  • Illinois — Chicago
  • Indiana — Fort Wayne, Indianapolis
  • Kansas — Kansas City
  • Kentucky — Louisville
  • Maryland — Baltimore
  • Massachusetts — Boston-Danvers, Boston-Norfolk
  • Michigan — Detroit, Grand Rapids, Lansing, Flint
  • Missouri — St. Louis
  • New Jersey — Delanco, Newark
  • New Mexico — Albuquerque
  • New York — Albany, Binghamton, Buffalo, New York, Rochester, Syracuse
  • Nevada — Las Vegas
  • North Carolina — Charlotte, Greensboro, Raleigh
  • Ohio — Akron, Canton, Cincinnati, Cleveland, Columbus, Toledo, Youngstown
  • Oklahoma — Oklahoma City
  • Pennsylvania — Allentown, Harrisburg, Lancaster, Pittsburgh, Scranton-Moosic, York-Hanover
  • South Carolina — Charleston, Columbia, Greenville, Myrtle Beach-Conway
  • Tennessee — Chattanooga, Knoxville, Memphis, Nashville
  • Texas — Austin, Beaumont, Blue Mound, Corpus Christi, Dallas, Houston, San Antonio
  • Virginia — Richmond, Virginia Beach
  • Washington D.C.
  • Wisconsin —Madison, Milwaukee

Customers have a couple options to complete their Carvana Experience:

  • Pick it up at a local Carvana Vending Machine location (listed below).
  • Fly and drive it back. If you live outside of the extended service area, you can fly, with a one-way ticket to a Vending Machine location. Carvana will arrange to white glove ship your car to the Vending Machine you choose. Then, you pick it up and drive it home. The company will even reimburse you up to $200 for your flight expenses.
  • Meet within the local radius. They can help find a local mutual meeting spot. Reduce your delivery fee allow you to pick a specific day and time. No waiting around for direct delivery.
  • Direct Delivery Process. If you live outside the local area, a third-party delivery company will bring it to you, for a non-refundable $399 fee. It takes an estimated 5-15 business days. If you do opt for direct delivery, you will get a Registration Box with paperwork and temporary license plate via FedEx before your car arrives. To help you get your car registered before the temporary plates expire, the package even comes with a return label. Users should know that shipping is on an uncovered trailer. So, though your new car may leave Carvana in perfect condition with a fresh wash and wax, it might arrive a little dirty. A $50 gift card in your registration box to buy the first car wash or tank of gas.

When you make a purchase on Carvana, buyers still take a 15-20 minute test drive upon either delivery or pickup.

To emphasize the easy, introvert-friendly, pressure-free experience, each pickup location is referred to as a car vending machine rather than a dealership. Carvana Vending Machine locations include the following:

  • Atlanta
  • Austin
  • Birmingham
  • Charlotte
  • Frisco
  • Gaithersburg
  • Houston
  • Indianapolis
  • Jacksonville
  • Nashville
  • Orlando
  • Philadelphia
  • Raleigh
  • San Antonio
  • Tampa
  • Tempe
  • Warrensville Heights

Top Ranked Companies

thumb_up

The Good

  • 100 Percent Online Buying Experience
  • High-Quality Inventory
  • Return and Warranty Policies
  • Sell or Trade-In Your Car
  • Carvana Financing

100 Percent Online Buying Experience

With Carvana, a new car can be fully purchased online at your own pace through the site. The site offers an online showroom-type experience with a unique HD 360-degree photo experience for every vehicle — with interior and exterior images of the actual vehicle listed.

While shopping, each car profile includes a free CarFax vehicle history report. You can also compare it to other models in your area. With an account, you can save favorite vehicles or a search that you commonly run. This online-only experience will be a plus for anyone who wishes to avoid a high-pressure sales experience.

High Quality Inventory

Carvana is very selective about the cars they choose to sell. Less than 10 percent of cars appraised are selected for the site.

All of the site’s inventory are Certified Pre-Owned vehicles and are put through a 150 point mechanical inspection. Additionally, vehicles that have been in a reported accident or have had structural or frame damage are never accepted.

The inspection process includes an oil change and a new coat of paint, wax, and seal. The company even suggests that you take your car to a certified mechanic to check it out during your test own period if you want.

Return and Warranty Policies

7 Day Return Policy

Although you aren’t truly purchasing a car sight unseen because of the online 3D showroom experience, you can still get peace of mind from Carvana’s return policy. Whether you pick up your car at a Carvana Vending Machine or you have it delivered, everyone gets a seven-day probationary period, which they call a Test Own. If you aren’t satisfied for any reason, you can cancel the purchase. Just contact customer support before 5 PM EST on the seventh day from your pickup or delivery.

Carvana will contact you on the sixth day to check on your satisfaction. If you’re not happy, they will pick it up and issue a refund.

There are a couple of things that customers should know about this policy:

  • 400-mile rule. Your test period comes with 400 free miles. If you go over that, you can still return the car, but there is a $1/mile fee.
  • Non-refundable Delivery Charge. If you had direct delivery because you live outside the local market, the $399 delivery fee is the only thing that won’t be refunded.
  • You can return or exchange the vehicle. You can even do up to two exchanges with week-long test drives. If you receive a third, then you forgo the chance to exchange it.
  • If the car has any modifications or damage, it can’t be returned.

100 Day Limited Warranty

Each purchase comes with a 100 day/4,189 mile Worry Free Guarantee through SilverRock, which covers basic and powertrain components. Carvana found that most people drive 41.89 miles on average in a given day, so the warranty is meant to actually last the average driver the full 100 days.

You can also opt for an added Extended Carvana Care warranty for an additional fee, if it’s offered on your vehicle.

Both warranties include roadside assistance and customers can contact customer service to add the extended warranty during your seven-day test own.

Sell or Trade-In Your Car

If you live in a local area or can meet in one, you can trade-in or sell your car to Carvana. You can fill out a quick appraisal online to get a no-haggle offer.

The company even hangs on to your trade in for the 7-day guarantee period, in case your new car doesn’t work out. However, if you did drive over 400 miles, you will have to pay the mileage fee before getting your trade-in back.

No trade-ins if you live outside the local area and get direct delivery.

Trade-ins don’t have to be up to Carvana’s rigorous quality standards. They just have to be able to safely do a test drive during the appraisal appointment, have a working odometer, and be newer than 1992.

Carvana Financing

Carvana offers its own car loan financing, serviced by Bridgecrest. Users can set financing terms with interactive dials and upload a few documents to complete their financing offer. You can even sign online.

Minimum requirements for financing:

  • At least 18
  • Make at least $10,000 yearly
  • No active bankruptcies

Although bad credit is accepted, approval is based on your credit history, annual income, and how much the vehicle costs. After you fill out a basic application for pre-approval, you will be able to see your personalized financing terms and monthly payment under each vehicle listing. Pre-approval is good for 45 days and only does a soft credit inquiry.

Once a customer chooses a car and selects to go forward with the buying process, then a hard credit check will be performed.

Check out our review of Carvana Car Loans.

thumb_down

The Bad

  • Delivery Fee
  • Single-Buyer Financing
  • Possible Delays
  • No Negotiation Policy
  • Third-Party Delivery

Delivery Fee

Carvana isn’t quite everywhere yet. If you live outside of a local delivery area (listed above), then you can choose to fly to pick it up and drive it back or pay for direct delivery, which costs $399.

While the fee is not a part of the actual car purchase itself, it can be included in your financing.

Regardless of how you take possession of the car, you are still eligible for the seven-day money back guarantee. The only catch is that if it was a direct delivery, the $399 fee is not refundable. Additionally, it can take 5-15 days for the car to be picked up. If you want to exchange for a different car, the first vehicle has to be confirmed as picked up before you can order another one, so you will be left waiting for a little while.

Single-Buyer Financing

While it is convenient that Carvana offers its own financing, it doesn’t allow anyone to co-sign with you. If you need to have a co-signed loan, then you can still shop with Carvana, but you will just have to finance through a third party option like a credit union or other lenders.

Possible Delays

If you live outside of the local area, it can take a bit to get your car due to unexpected delays like transportation or weather issues.

Additionally, before your car is loaded up to be delivered to you, a pre-delivery inspection is performed, including a test drive. If any cosmetic or mechanical issues are found, there may be a delay while they fix it.

If there are any delays, a customer service rep will contact you and you will get updates via email, phone, or text.

No-Negotiation Policy

Carvana is a haggle-free company. Cars are competitively priced and free of dealer or document fees, but also set prices are non-negotiable.

If you are the type who would like leeway to negotiate your trade-in, this is not the place for you. As part of the company’s effort to provide a hassle-free experience, after you fill out the online appraisal, that is your final offer. There is no price matching or haggling for a trade-in credit value.

Third-Party Delivery

While it is clearly great to deal with Carvana and its customer-first policies, it is hard to say what the delivery experience will be like with its local delivery partners across the country.

gavel

The Bottom Line

Carvana is an e-commerce platform that offers an easy car buying experience for people who don’t want to play games when car shopping. A technology friendly business model lets users avoid talking to any salespeople and truly buy a car online, even down to the auto loan. This is the car website that many used car shoppers have been dreaming of.

Honestly, the only reason why we were able to find “Bad” things about buying a car online with this company is because the site’s online FAQs are so transparent regarding the company’s standard procedures and customer service policies.

Most other car finders will not have the same types of cons because they do not offer a full-service experience.

View Best Car Finders

Was this content helpful?
thumb_up Yes thumb_down No

Star Rating

info

2.2

star star star_border star_border star_border

250 Reviews

Review Breakdown

5 grade

21%

4 grade

6%

3 grade

4%

2 grade

10%

1 grade

59%

Sentiment Criteria

Value

star star star_half star_border star_border

Quality

star star star_half star_border star_border

Service

star star star_half star_border star_border

Trustworthiness

star star star_border star_border star_border
cancel
info
star star star star_border star_border

Eileen Kelly Belleville, NJ

Pros: Ease of use, shop from the comfort of your home, no haggling, good trade-in value Cons: Delivery is undependable, poor customer service I have purchased two cars from Carvana. The first car had a delivery delay in July 2020. I was disappointed, but since I had a car that I could drive, which I was trading in, I was understanding and figured it was just one of those things. I am in the process of buying a second car from Carvana. It is a 17th birthday gift for my twins. Got a confirmation email this morning that the car is on its way for delivery tomorrow at noon, as scheduled. A few hours later I get another email saying it's going to be delayed for a few days. My kids' birthday is tomorrow. This is beyond disappointing. I called Carvana and explained the situation but they said there was nothing they could do. I asked for money off and they offered me a whopping $100. I asked if I could go pick it up wherever it is but they said it hasn't even been inspected yet. Poor customer service and delivery dates mean nothing. I had been recommending Carvana to lots of people, but now that's 2 for 2 on not delivering on time.

5 years ago

star star star star_border star_border

Nancy Johnson Hendersonville, TN

It started out great ! It took me 3 tries to get the right SUV for me ! First one I wasnt comfortable about what I learned about the tranny problems with the Rouge ! 2nd I tried Honda CRV and I was put off by the condition of the headlights when they brought it then the tire icon was on , they were all low on air so I filled them to proper amount and the icon never went out which probably means the sensor is bad ! I was told that I needed to go have the light turned off when that happens ! Lol OK ? I know better than that ! I love the Honda even though there was a vibration in idle so I decided to get a newer model for the 3rd try ! During those phone calls the ppl weren't very nice , condinsending I'd say ! So I'm looking forward to the 2018 ! Would I buy a car this way again ? I guess so ! I was disappointed in the supposed 150 point inspection of the cars ! Don't believe it's TRUE

6 years ago

star star star star_border star_border

thomas pinkerton Redding, CA

So far I have nothing but issues with the service. The car has damage that was not reported when I bought the car. I had to pay hundreds of dollars to have the car delivered to my home and then the driver they hired refused to deliver the car to my home and I'm getting no type of resinable compensation for the treatment from the driver they hired (the driver they hired told me he owns the transport company so he will deliver my car when he wants to and told me to f off then hung up on me he was also in violation per carvanas employee of his contract with me and them but nothing comes of it to make things right with the customer.) Now they are telling me I have to go get a bunch of extra things done to the car to complete the registration. No one has ever said anything about any of this to me. Then I call to ask questions on the paperwork and get told less then 5 minutes wait time we'll 25 minutes later and I get put back on hold to revive no help because the person who is answering the line for the registration help dose not know the answer and can't get the answer for me.

6 years ago

star star star star_border star_border

Kane Kenworthy Indianapolis, IN

They are very specific with what they will repair on your vehicle. I had a significant amount of rust on the frame and requested help with paying for repair and prevention, but they declined. They also automatically charge $350 for title and registration. My fees totaled $182. I requested to have my specialty plates transferred and they never communicated that they couldn't, and after talking to a rep for a while, he explained that they won't cover the $40 specialty cost, which is still significantly less than $350. They went ahead and sent me registration for normal plates but never communicated that they didn't do the transfer. Overall, I got what I wanted, but with lots of red tape, and little explanation.

6 years ago

star star star star_border star_border

Judith Everts Celina, OH

I love my new car and believe I got a fair trade in value for my old one, however I did experience some problems with Carvana. I was told that in Indiana a new plate/registration would take about 2 weeks. I got my new registration after 7 weeks, three days after my temporary plates expired. No new plate came with it. I contacted Carvana and they said I was supposed to keep my old plate. The driver that delivered my new car and took my old one said no trip to the BMV was required, that they handled all of that. He made no mention of removing my old plates. So here I am off the the BMV to find out how much it will cost me for a replacement plate. I'm not very happy about all this, however, everything else went smoothly and I got exactly the car I wanted.

6 years ago

star star star star_border star_border

Giovanni hernandez Brooklyn, NY

I love carvana. I had bought a car before hand and its was a great experience , got it the day i was suppose to ,great car , but as of recent they have been slacking , ordered a car and suppose to come on sept 2 , got an email a day before and had the delicery delayed. Then again delayed , then was reccomended to a diferent car, so i did, and same thing. Was suppose to get it on the 16 of september, and it got delayed till sept 30 , and thats if it ready by then, what im trying to say is they should really keep the delivery date as how one is suppose to get it delivered , i sold my other car thinking it would be coming, now i have no car at all ,still waiting for my new one to come by

7 years ago

star star star star_border star_border

Debbie K

I got a great deal on my car, it was delivered promptly, and the experience had been great until my temporary registration was due to expire. I called today to find out that my car's permanent registration will not be completed until a week after the 45 day temporary plate expires. I was on the phone with them for almost an hour and all they could do was offer to reimburse me for an Uber or a rental during the period my car would be unregistered. Why would it take more than 45 days to register a car in CT? It's ridiculous and it has adversely affected my opinion of the Carvana buying process. I am not happy and would no longer recommend Carvana for CT buyers.

7 years ago

star star star star_border star_border

Chris bell , GA

I bought a car from Carvana last week and I’m really disappointed right now. The car I received had too many issues that I should not have to deal with. For starters the interior was dirty from the headliner to the hard surfaces, behind the seats, etc. Next there’s a nail in the tire and shaking when driving over 40mph also shake when braking. The delivery process was honestly the best part of the of all this. Can’t really say I’ll stay or get another car from Carvana.

6 years ago

star star star star_border star_border

keith La Vernia, TX

Car buying was easy. However the car arrived over a week late with a flat tire. Promised $200 rebate that we never received. The car has mismatched tires and one tire is a directional tire that was put on backwards. The tires they did not change didn't last more than 1000 miles. All 4 rotors are warped. There is no way this BMW could've possibly passed the inspection they say they put it through. Very disappointed in their misrepresentation of the vehicle and the inspection process. On top of that you will never get anyone from Carvana to call you back after your purchase go through.

7 years ago

star star star star_border star_border

Jeannette Smith Philadelphia, PA

Great first time car buying experience. However still waiting to be reimbursed for car inspection. Everytime I call no one seems to know why I would have to get my car inspected. Been waiting for months now for close to one hundred dollars

6 years ago

star star star star_border star_border

Morgan Tennant Shelley, ID

Carvana is a great resource to look for cars, however, there is often a very large fee to get the car delivered if you don't live near a dealership.

5 years ago