Thrifty Logo
star star star star_half star_border

4.4

Overall Score

Author: Kaitlyn Short

LAST UPDATED: February 28th, 2022

Top Ranked Companies

thumb_up

The Good

  • Competitive pricing
  • Available in 46 states
  • Online check-in

Economy Price Range

Thrifty's economy cars are priced low in the car rental industry. We found that, with Thrifty, car rental prices were contingent upon location and the type of car procured. Thrifty does a unique price-matching program, where they will honor lower rental rates and give you a ten percent discount.

Luxury Price Range

Thrifty also rents luxury vehicles, the rental price is average in the industry. For customers who would like to rent luxury cars, Thrifty may be a great option with the high availability and the

States Available

Thrifty can be found in 46/50 states. This almost covers every state-a huge advantage over the average car rental company who covers only a fraction of that. It also benefits travelers and local residents who are in these places or are traveling to these places.

Airports Locations

Thrifty has rental counters at most major airports throughout the United States and Canada. This makes renting cars for travelers more convenient and easy.

Online Check-In

Thrifty has online check-in, allowing you to check in before you show up. Customers are required to provide a few pieces of information, including license number, date of birth, and a few pieces of information about driving records. While rental counters can have slow lines and long waits, checking in online speeds up the process and gets customers driving away in their vehicle more quickly.
thumb_down

The Bad

  • Roadside assistance availability
  • No instant return
  • No on-site fuel discount

Roadside Assistance

Thrifty offers what they call Protection Packages, which offer 24 hours a day Premium Roadside Assistance Service. These packages, although good, are only available at U.S. Corporate Locations and at participating licensee locations. You have to ask the rental counter for the availability of any of the packages. Thrifty sets it up so that if you want one of the following protection packages you add it to your online reservation and get more information about the package (i.e. price) when you pick up your vehicle. This is not a good option because you should be informed of how much these packages cost before you get there in person to rent the car. Other companies charge an additional fee for roadside assistance as a separate item without having to buy a whole package that you may not be able to afford.

Instant Return

With Thrifty, vehicles must be returned to the rental counter. This is standard operating procedure with most rental companies. Instant return can be a very convenient feature that some companies offer which allows the customer to leave the keys in the car and leave.

On-Site Fuel Discount

There is no on-site fuel discount with Thrifty. They do have a prepaid fuel option. When you return the car with an empty tank, you pay the amount to fill it up, multiplied by the manufacturer's gallon-per-tank capacity. It would make it more advantageous if an on-site fueling discount was offered to help offset traveling expenses.
gavel

The Bottom Line

Thrifty has a high availability and has a presence in 46 states. Thrifty also offers competitive economy prices, and a decent amount of variety in their vehicles. For very frequent travelers, they will receive a free rental day for every sixteen they pay for-a great perk for customer loyalty. Because of these factors, we recommend considering Thrifty for your car rental needs.
Was this content helpful?
thumb_up Yes thumb_down No

Star Rating

info

3.4

star star star star_half star_border

52 Reviews

Review Breakdown

5 grade

19%

4 grade

40%

3 grade

17%

2 grade

8%

1 grade

15%

Sentiment Criteria

Value

star star star star_half star_border

Quality

star star star star_half star_border

Service

star star star star_half star_border

Trustworthiness

star star star star_half star_border
cancel
info
star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Brooke Z Cleveland, OH

My flight was delayed. I was unable to pick the car up until the second day into the rental, due to my flight being delayed. When my plane landed at my destination on the first day of the reservation,the car rental facility was closed, which caused me to not be able to pick the car up until the second day.I contacted customer service in regards to being credited for the day we DID NOT have the car and I was refused my request. This is terrible customer service. I was penalized for a situation that was out of my control and in not so many words told, "too bad, deal with it". In the future I will take my business elsewhere.

4 years ago

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

T. Dorsz Frederick, MD

I rented a car through one of Thrify's resellers. I prepaid to get a better rate. I turned the car in early because of all the shutdowns of National Parks. Thrifty will not adjust my cost. They are completely unflexible during the CORVID-19 national emergency. They would not adjust the transportation fees, or remove any of the days that I did not rent the car. I went from renting 41 days down to 21. The only thing they adjusted were the number of days for insurance. One of their offices said they were waiving transportation fees. They did not. They said they could adjust the contract type but that it would be more expensive since my daily rate would go up. This was a very expensive lesson for me. BEWARE the consequences of pre-payment options and using Thrifty's resellers. This was my first time renting through them. It's my last.

6 years ago

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Chris Sulphur, LA

PRICE GOUGING AT IT'S BEST! I called Thrifty to rent a Large SUV from the Denver Airport about a month ago for my 5 day trip to visit my daughter in Keystone, Co. from 2/21/20-2/26/20. I was told that Thrifty could not guarantee an AWD or 4WD, so I decided to rent a Minivan since it would be guaranteed front wheel drive. The price was $204 and with taxes and fees was $283.50. Upon arriving at the Denver Airport Thrifty location I had to wait 45 minutes in line before actually getting to the counter. At the counter I was presented a piece of paper basically stating that I needed an AWD/4WD or could be ticked or possibly wouldn't make it back to the airport. There were only two vehicles that would work because of the amount of people and luggage we had one was a pickup truck or a large suv. I asked what the cost difference was, well the cost for the truck was $120 more per day or my other option was $200 more per day. I could not believe this and I asked to talk to manager. Still in disbelief of the price in which I was told that's the price I asked the manager about being a blue chip member, veteran or I had an email with one day free from Thrifty and was ignored by the manager and said that's it either you want the vehicle or we need to start waiting on other customers, again the line is almost out the door so I took it. We get to the truck it's an extended cab not even a crew cab no running boards nothing. Thinking I was stuck we take the truck at a total cost of $1040 so 5 times the price of my Minivan. I call Thrifty customer service the following day and they agree I'm being way overcharged but get this there's nothing they can do only tell me to drive back to Denver which is approximately an 1.5 hr drive away turn the truck in, call reservations and make a new reservation. I requested a supervisor call me back gave my number and have never gotten the call back. I've rented from Thrifty multiple times I've never been treated like this and am very disappointed in customer service obviously they don't care because I know I'm only one person and they're a multi-billion dollar company. My reason for writing this is hopefully this doesn't happen to you. Member Number: 0724928515 Reservation: J30307376D9

6 years ago

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Greg Hanold Batesville, MS

The counter in Fort Wayne Airport for Thrifty / Hertz is very unreliable and dishonest. Horrible Customer Service and fails to follow through. It now has been close to 2 months and still no contact from Thrifty. I was told 7 different times I would be receiving calls. 3 of those calls were to be from Area Managers to resolve the issue. No one has ever contacted me. I initially spoke with Dan at the Fort Wayne Airport and he was the one who told me he would investigate and get back to me. NEVER HAPPENED. DAN, YOU NEVER CALLED BACK!!! Thrifty's crappy customer service informed me Thrifty wasn't responsible for lost items... I told her the item wasn't lost... it was stolen by a Thrifty employee in Fort Wayne... No surprise, there was no response.

7 years ago

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

James Milton

If you rent from this company BEWARE. The person behind the counter will do everything they can to get all the extra crap all for fee's. Also you better READ the contract. I refused all the options except for the GPS which was $11.95/per day. At the end of the spiel she had me initial and sign the contract. OK, no problem until I got the bill! Turns out all that initialing was all of the options! So I ended up paying more than double the rental. I called them and they said tough luck, you signed it, It's your baby. I trusted the lady at the counter and told her verbally what did and didn't want before signing. What a fool I was for trusting them. WATCH OUT!

9 years ago

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Dixie St. Petersburg, FL

I picked up the car at the Tampa Airport the day after Thanksgiving. The recon center did a horrible job cleaning the car, and there was even trash under the seat. The outside was dirty and still covered with bugs. But being a holiday and so few cars available, I accepted it. I returned the car cleaner than when I picked it up. Just received my credit card statement and there was a $400 fee. Called Thrifty, and they said it was a $400 smoking fee. I was the only one in the car, and I do not smoke. Geeeezzzz what a waste of my time having to call and get the charge reversed.

4 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

anna blaser St Louis, MO

I don’t like Thrifty at all. I rented one once, and even though they said it was clean, it wasn’t. It was also very clear that someone had been smoking in the car. Poor experience.

4 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Amy N Sandy, UT

Awful experience. They're not business traveler friendly. And the car smelled bad.

4 years ago