CarMax Logo
star star star star_half star_border

5.1

Overall Score

Author: Kaitlyn Short

LAST UPDATED: April 9th, 2022

If you’re looking to buy a car from—or sell your car to— a trusted brand name, CarMax is certainly worth being one of the first options you try. The company’s first location opened in 1993 as an experiment suggested by executives at the Circuit City electronics corporation. The project, nicknamed “Honest Rick’s Used Cars”, was meant to expand Circuit City’s enterprise into other arenas. What became known as CarMax fulfilled that goal, growing rapidly across the United States through various acquisitions of car manufacturing real estate.

Currently headquartered in Richmond, Virginia, the company currently operates 195 used car stores in 94 markets. CarMax.com strives to offer superior quality used and certified pre-owned vehicles, as well as friendly service to its customers. The CarMax company has consistently been named as one of FORTUNE® 500’s “100 Best Companies to Work For” for 10 straight years. It has been serving customers for over 59 years, holding themselves to a high standard of integrity with their services and products.

Read on for CarMax pros and cons, plus CarMax reviews from users.  

Top Ranked Companies

thumb_up

The Good

  • Focus on Customer Experience
  • Quality Inspection & Guarantees
  • Transfer Used Cars to a Location Near You
  • Great Used Car Resources & Tools
  • Sell or Trade-In Options

Focus on Customer Experience

CarMax is the largest used car retailer on and off the internet, allowing customers to shop for vehicles the same way they shop for products at what they call "big-box" retailers-sort of like a Costco or Sam's Club for the car shopping and buying experience. This refers to promising car shoppers an affordable purchase price with a no-haggle price model, a broad selection of CarMax Quality Certified Pre-Owned vehicles, and superior customer service.

CarMax's car buying process is based on the results of a notable consumer survey the company conducted back in 1991. The survey asked everyday consumers about their preferences when it comes to the process of buying a car. The answers below are what define today's CarMax's shopping experience. What this means for you the customer:

  • Customers said they don't like playing games, so CarMax lets you know the price right away, not after hours of haggling and mind games. 
  • Customers said they don't like their time being wasted, so CarMax lets you have one salesperson work with you from start to finish who won't make you drive all over town to find the right car.
  • Customers said they want security, so the company inspects and reconditions all cars and backs them with a CarMax 30 day warranty so you don't have to worry what will happen when you drive off the lot. They also come with a free AutoCheck vehicle history report. 
  • Customers wanted more fun and less pressure from car salespeople, so CarMax employees are trained to offer assistance without being pushy.

Quality Inspection & Guarantees

CarMax has a sizeable listing of used cars (new cars as well) that support its promise to offer security to customers. Each used vehicle has to be CarMax Quality Certified, meaning every used car must pass a Certified Quality Inspection.

Each used car sold also comes with a 5-Day Money-Back Guarantee, as well as a 30-Day Limited Warranty (and a 60-Day Warranty in Connecticut, Minnesota and Rhode Island and 90 Days in Massachusetts and New York).

Additionally, each used car buyer has the option of purchasing a MaxCare Extended Service plan covering the following:

  • Climate control
  • Cooling system
  • Drivetrain
  • Electrical systems
  • Electronics
  • Engine
  • Steering
  • Suspension
  • Transmission

The extended warranty is offered through MaxCare, a third-party warranty company. Deductibles start at $50 per visit. Customers who purchase the extended warranty will also receive emergency roadside assistance and rental reimbursement. The website provides a free coverage estimate based on how many miles you drive, your type of car, and your desired deductible.

Transfer Used Cars to a Location Near You

CarMax can transfer any used car you are considering to a local car dealership near you, so you can test drive it at your convenience. Transfer fees may be applicable, but oftentimes this service is free.

Consumers are encouraged to ask a CarMax sales representative about this nationwide transfer service and any possible fees ahead of time.

There is no obligation to buy the car once it is transferred.

Great Used Car Resources & Tools

There are plenty of resources at CarMax.com to help you find a vehicle. Read thousands of research articles, ratings, and reviews on the CarMax website.

For used car shoppers, this car retailer has a nice array of tools like a payment calculator to calculate and compare monthly payments and overall affordability.

What's unique, however, is their Tax, Title, Tags, and Fees Calculator and their MPG Savings Calculator. The Tax, Title, Tags, and Fees Calculator helps you figure out what sales tax, title, and tags fees you will need to pay, according to what state you reside in. All you have to do is select your state and vehicle price range and hit the Calculate button. If you're unsure about what fee rules and regulations apply to your next auto purchase, this is a perfect car shopper's tool.

The MPG (Miles Per Gallon) Savings calculator allows you to see how a vehicle's fuel economy will affect your bottom line. It actually allows you to compare two cars at once to see how they stack up against each other. This is a great tool to determine long-term maintenance costs for car ownership. To find out how much you'll save (or lose), locate the desired car's gas mileage on the Carmax vehicle profiles you selected, then fill in the average MPG of two cars you'd like to compare and hit "Calculate Savings."

Sell or Trade-In Options

CarMax.com will also buy or trade-in your current vehicle no matter what condition it is in. An owner can get a free written offer that is good for 7 days at any CarMax dealership location. If you choose to sell your car to CarMax, you will receive a bank draft on the spot that may be deposited in your bank right away.

Another unique component for consumers is being able to sell their car to CarMax. Although CarMax is not the only car buying service site doing this, it is the only one that offers a unique appraisal process to see what your car is worth. The appraisal process looks like this:

  • Fast and free—your appraisal can take as little as 30 minutes and you're welcome to watch while you wait.
  • No obligation—CarMax will buy your car even if you don't buy theirs.
  • No appointment needed—bring your car in for an appraisal any time they're open.
  • CarMax appraisers—specially trained to evaluate the cars they buy.
  • The written offer—it's good for seven days at any CarMax location.
  • Fast payment—upon selling CarMax your car, you'll receive a bank draft on the spot!

The appraisal process is Step two in a streamlined, no-hassle, three-step selling process—the result of the code of conduct based on consumer's preferences previously mentioned. 

  • Step One is to bring in your car to one of CarMax's dealer locations. Making an appointment is optional, but you'd probably be better off making one—especially if you have a busy schedule. 
  • Step Two is to get a written offer. This comes after the appraisal process and is good for seven days. 
  • Step Three is the final step where you have the option to complete the sale transaction, trade it, or think it over. CarMax will buy your car regardless of make, miles, or condition.
thumb_down

The Bad

  • Issues with MPG Savings Calculator
  • Spread Out Locations

Issues with MPG Savings Calculator

CarMax has a lot to offer used car buyers and sellers with only a few inconveniences. For example, the MPG Savings calculator is a great tool-it would be even greater if you could just find out the miles per gallon savings on one car instead of having to compare two. When searching the site, if you're only interested in one vehicle, you can't use the tool.

Spread Out Locations

Another inconvenience is that if you are not living near one of CarMax's locations, taking advantage of 'sell to CarMax' or trade-in process may not be viable. As store locations are so spread out and possibly in a state other than your own, you may need to make travel arrangements or you may be unable to afford the trip either time-wise or money-wise. (This is where the Tax, title, tags, and fees calculator comes in handy).

gavel

The Bottom Line

CarMax offers lots of tools to help people with buying and selling cars, trucks, and SUVs. What makes CarMax so massive is that, unlike many online auto companies, they are not just an internet business. The company has brick-and-mortar car dealerships around the country—although very spread out.

Getting to one of their locations may be an issue, but since CarMax will buy your car regardless of make, miles, or condition, if you plan on selling your car or are looking to buy one yourself, their website is one worth exploring.

View Best Car Finder Companies

Was this content helpful?
thumb_up Yes thumb_down No

Star Rating

info

3.6

star star star star_half star_border

200 Reviews

Review Breakdown

5 grade

44%

4 grade

24%

3 grade

7%

2 grade

3%

1 grade

24%

Sentiment Criteria

Value

star star star star_half star_border

Quality

star star star star_half star_border

Service

star star star star_half star_border

Trustworthiness

star star star star_half star_border
cancel
info
star star star star star

susie Littleton, CO

As I strolled thru all the reviews and was shocked to read that there were bad reviews. I bought a 2016 Mercedes E350 last spring I saw it on line and quickly went down to see if it was avail and it was my husband was coming in to town 2 days later and they were happy to put the car on hold (there were 2 other customers looking at the car as well). I always do my due diligence and look at cost comparisons of the same car and the Mercedes dealership in Peoria was selling the same car for $10,000 more. Two days later I went and purchased the car and by far it was the easiest transaction I have ever been thru I was there less than an hour even with financing. Fast forward 2 1/2 months down the road my break censor went off and I was out of state. I made an appointment with the Mercedes dealership then realized they gave me 90 days for a Carmax warranty so I took it to the nearest Carmax dealership they found the back breaks needed to be replaced as they said when I purchased the car the break pads were on the "line". Needless to say they fixed the breaks no charge and the service department was top notch and very professional as was the dealership that I bought it from in Arizona Tolleson dealership. I will never go to anywhere else to purchase a car CarMax as a life customer!!

6 years ago

star star star star star

Aline DeSoto, TX

I've bought 4 cars from CarMax & I've had a great experience each time. I just recently purchased my 4th this past weekend. Unlike other dealers, they don't drag you through a long, all day process of haggling & trying to get you to buy extra bs. You go in, find what you like, test drive, look at financing, review if you want warranty, GAP, & go to signing. If there's any little imperfections like chipped paint or what not, you can bring it back within 30 days and they'll touch it up. I made the mistake once & bought a car from another dealer outside of CarMax & found out the frame was twisted. CarMax guarantees their vehicles. I will never buy a car from anywhere else but CarMax.

7 years ago

star star star star star

Eddie Rios Ogden, UT

Superb experience with CarMax. I found a luxury car at commuter car prices. The inventory of cars was immense. The quality of cars was awesome. Very cleaned up, beyond what I had expected. And the staff was on the ball. They made the entire car buying experience easy. This is not what used car buying used to be. CarMax has changed the approach and it has made all the difference for the positive and the exceptional.

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Cam Hall Palmyra, VA

I've used CarMax to trade-in my car, buy a car, and learn more about cars through their wealth of info. When I traded in my car, they made sure I had the best offer by one-upping a competitor immediately, no questions asked. When I purchased a car they answered all of my questions, offered multiple test drives, and even offered a significant return policy. I also use Carmax constantly when browsing for other vehicles and look at their AWESOME pictures/videos for cars, and use their search and filtering on their site. CarMax helped reinstate trust in car dealerships for me after years of bad experiences.

4 years ago Edited January 3, 2022

star star star star star

Lynette Jorgensen Herriman, UT

CarMax has a wide variety of vehicles at competitive prices. The website shows the price and fees of the vehicle you are interested in so there are not surprises or guessing what the vehicle would cost. I appreciate their transparency!

4 years ago

star star star star star

Kaysha Love Las Vegas, NV

CarMax is a company that thrives to ensure their customers are getting the most truthful rate on their cars. Ive been pleasantly surprised to see just how much this company genuinely cares about giving people the best price along with offering great warranties.

6 years ago

star star star star star

Han Sell

I purchased 2 cars through CarMax. They found the exact car I was looking for and had me in the driver's seat within a few days for the first car and a few weeks for the second because it was delivered from out of state. Great customer service. I will use them again.

6 years ago

star star star star star

Paul Weimar

They are great professionals. Every step of the way. It starts at the front door. There were no salesmen outside that rush up to us. No fighting to help us. They asked how they could help. They took time to explain Two hours later we drove away in our new to us used car. Wonderful.

6 years ago

star star star star star

Hannah Pleasant Grove, UT

We had a great experience with CarMax. We test-drove a 2011 Nissan Rogue and enjoyed a pressure-free, friendly experience. We were very thankful. We didn't end up buying because we changed our mind on the model, but we were happy with the experience nonetheless.

8 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Becca Jones Bel Air, MD

The start of a car search can be overwhelming and a real hassle. However neither of these are the case with CarMax. When searching for a new car, I was able to search for exactly what I wanted and within my set budget. I was able to search for cars close to my area, within my budget, with the proper mileage as well as the make I was looking for. After setting up an appointment online, I was able to purchase my car after test driving in person. Now I’m the proud owner of a Hyundai Elantra all thanks to the CarMax website.

4 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Matthew Wadley San Diego, CA

We purchased our 2008 Honda Pilot from them. Everything was straight forward and they had a lot of options for us to choose from. There was no pressure to buy, they pretty much said here is the breakdown and do you want to buy. There was no getting a manager to try to convince us or strong-arm us. I was actually a little upset that I couldn't haggle with them to save a couple of hundred dollars

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Greg West Valley City, UT

We have bought three vehicles from CarMax and recommended it to our grown children and friends. We have heard nothing but good comments from them and our experience has been great. My wife surprised me with a badly needed car upgrade from CarMax. She chose between two vehicles, not sure which I would prefer. They told her she could trade it in about 15 minutes if it was within three days. After driving the one she chose, I decided I would prefer the other and the switch was totally painless.

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Stephanie Love Herriman, UT

Car max was great when I bought a car from them. I love that they don’t haggle the prices with you and the price is the price and I always feel like I’m getting a great deal. The customer service was awesome too. They answered all my questions and some. They took me out test driving several vehicles without getting annoyed. I even took a few out several times and never felt any pressure or annoyance. They were great to work with.

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Lorna Johnston West Valley City, UT

We have bought three cars from CarMax and the experience was far better than any other car buying experiences we have had. The second car we got was a surprise for my husband and it was down to two cars. They told me if he decided he wanted to pick a the one I didn’t get for him, he could trade if it was within three days. He liked the one I picked but decided he would rather have the other one. The trade was quick and totally pain free. Every interaction with CarMax has been great.

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Ted Johnson Pleasant Grove, UT

I have used CarMax for 4 cars to date and counting. I don't have to worry about a used car breaking down with CarMax and their no haggle way of doing things is refreshing. Love their selections of vehicles and they have a wide variety for everyone. The people are great to work with and I like their shop as well if I need a fix up and their warranties are the best.

7 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

kristin Gneiting Pleasant Grove, UT

I have used CarMax for about 7 cars. I have grown to love their service, their no haggle salesman are the best. They are more interested in making me happy and finding what works for me than making the sale. I also like their extended warranties, their great quality and inspected cars and their ability to be able to match you up with a loan that is best for you.

7 years ago

star star star star star

Natalia Correa MDTribe Tallahassee, FL

I worked with Carmax in the past when my boyfriend was trying to get a car. They are very patient and really work hard to meet your needs when looking for a car! Highly recommend checking them out!

6 years ago

star star star star star

Shannon S Orlando, FL

Nadir was FABULOUS! He was patient and kind and knowledgeable. I trusted him right away. The car I thought I wanted wasn't a good fit for me and helped put me in the right one. He deserves a raise.

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Heather Riverton, UT

Carmax provides a great used car shopping experience. They have lots of vehicle options on their lot. So, it's easy to see and test drive various options. Also, you can see the vehicle options online that they have at their physical location before going in.

4 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Jenni Zollinger Aiken, SC

My mother asked me to help her with selling her car. We went to CarMax and were very pleased with the price we were given as well as the helpful staff there who made the transaction very smooth. She was very pleased. Will certainly use them again.

4 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Steven Shimmin

Bought both of my children's first cars there, fair price, good selection Reasonable priced and good quality cars. Sales people can be a little pushy and rude but that may be typical of that profession? I will go there again

4 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

David Swenson Commerce City, CO

Amazing tool that changes the game of shopping for abused car. I used Carmax to find the exact Toyota Tacoma I wanted (in the middle of Nebraska)! I will use them again in the future because of their huge national inventory and search database.

4 years ago Edited January 5, 2022

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Karen Torino Tallahassee, FL

Car max will have almost any car you are looking for. They also have pretty good prices and are willing to offer you any information on the car you may need. What I liked most is that the options to choose from were not limited, and there were all sorts of cars available.

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Scott C. Lehi, UT

I have bought several cars from CarMax and would have no problem purchasing from there again. Particularly my last experience was pleasant with zero pressure from the sales person, and once we were wanting to move forward and needed more definitive information, we were referred to another sales person who was very helpful.

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Michelle Rios Ogden, UT

We used CarMax to find my husbands Mercedes Benz. He was able use their website to find the exact car he was looking for. He submitted the request and several options popped up. He was then able to select the one he wanted and have it delivered to the store nearby. The process was fun and the service was great.

6 years ago

star star star star star

Syl North Port, FL

The purpose of my visit to CarMax was to sell my vehicle. The service I received was excellent. The employee was well trained and knowledgeable. I really liked the service I received. The purpose of my visit to CarMax was the band of my vehicle.

6 years ago

star star star star star

Keri Wilson Houston, TX

I have bought 3 vehicles from Carmax and have not been disappointed yet. The cars you have to select from are quality vehicles. Their warrenty's are worth paying for. I know when I buy a used vehicle from Carmax in getting a good vehicle.

6 years ago

star star star star star

Mickey Wilson Sacramento, CA

We used CarMax to buy my granddaughter her first car, it was used so we got the warranty with it. Over the years there hasn’t been many problems with the car but when there has been we’ve always been able to take the car in to CarMax and they fix it with no problems!

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Brenda Mertes Houston, TX

CarMax made the car-buying experience anything but boring. Great customer service and they are very cooperative with credit scores. The used cars they keep on their lots are always superb as well. The customer service is terrific and we had a salesman that was highly patient with us while we looked around and took our time filling out the forms.

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Amy Boren American Fork, UT

We used this site to look for a car for our daughter who was leaving to go away to college. It was super easy to use and brought up a bunch of cars in our price range and qualification. It really helped us narrow it down to what we wanted!

7 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Reese Pleasant Grove, UT

I have bought no less than 5 cars from CarMax and they helped me find the best car for me every time. Great salespeople that were very helpful and not pushy at all. The cars are in great shape and I like that they help you line up the loan as well and provide warranties that give you peace of mind.

7 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Ashley Pleasant Grove, UT

We love the ease and convenience of having CarMax find us the quality used car that we are looking for. We have had cars shipped from California to Las Vegas for only a $100 dollars. It is fun to be able to look online and see what Cars are available and we trust the CarMax name.

7 years ago

star star star star star

Mia Hernandez Tempe, AZ

this is one of my favorite car finders website to use when i was searching for a new car your able to filter your options to only look at the types of cars your interested in and honestly its all just really user friendly and i feel like i have all the information i need at my finger tips

7 years ago

star star star star star

Amber C Frey San Diego, CA

I purchased my vehicle through CarMax and overall it was a nice experience. The salesman was not pushy at all and as soon as I picked out my Chrysler 200, the payment/paperwork process we pretty quick and painless. I've had my car for going on 2 years now and haven't had any issues with it. I will probably buy from them again in the future.

7 years ago

star star star star star

Kara Turkson Tallahassee, FL

CarMax consolidates the car buying experience so that you end up with a wide range of options but not all the confusion on where to go and who you need to speak with.

4 years ago

star star star star star

Jackson Barousse Kenner, LA

CarMax has some of the best customer services of any business I have ever visited. Their attention to detail and care for the customer's well-being is unmatched.

6 years ago

star star star star star

Jadon Barre Marietta, GA

Carmax is an easy way to find everything I need in a vehicle and stay within my price range. It’s organized and the customer service is helpful and friendly.

6 years ago

star star star star star

JDWain Tallahassee, FL

I have used Car Max a few times to buy used cars. I find that they usually have very competitive prices and great and knowledgeable salesmen to help me with my car purchase

6 years ago

star star star star star

Randal hyde Springfield, MO

CarMax provides a great way to find new cars in my area and provide comparable prices for cars that I am interested in. Their website is easy to navigate.

7 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Bryan Peterson Herriman, UT

I have traded in a car and bought a car from CarMax. I have also traded in a car but not bought. The value I got for my trade-in was several thousand more than what I would have had at a traditional dealership

4 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Taylor Jorgensen Herriman, UT

I have been impressed with the ease of finding quality used cars on CarMax website. They are very transparent with their prices/fees. There is no pressure from their salespeople.

4 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Luke Swierczynski Waterford, MI

They offered me the competitive offer on my car instantly and didn't lower it at all upon inspection when I turned it in. Walked out with a check same day and didn't have to deal with anything else.

4 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Karen Torino Tallahassee, FL

CarMax is great for finding cars for sale. They have even offered good money for a car that I owned due to a shortage in a specific piece. They are fair and always willing to work with you.

4 years ago

star star star star star

Sydney Charleston South Jordan, UT

Bought a car from Carmax & they were wonderful! Salesman was respectful, helpful & knowledgeable. Entire process was seamless. The office was clean and everyone was very friendly

5 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Mark Benson Nakhon Sawan, 60

I bought my wife’s Honda Accord off of CarMax.com. It was affordable and fairly easy to purchase. We got it in good condition and didn’t have to struggle with car salesmen to get it.

5 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Jacobrobot321 Leesville, LA

CarMax always has helped me with reviewing cars I’m interested in purchasing and seeing if they are worth it or not. My current car was found on CarMax and I can say that they are true to advertisement with true facts

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

cb Thibodaux, LA

CarMax is a great website when looking for a car! Every car on their website is well kept and mainly has not very many miles on them. They supply pictures and as many details as they can about each car.

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Maryann Renteria (Mckrae) Phoenix, AZ

I really loved being able to take my car in and have it checked out and then within a short time being told what my car is actually worth! No haggling on prices! What you see is final price!

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

Tiffany I Elkridge, MD

Carmax is the best car search. I will never buy anywhere else. It was so easy to purchase my car - didn’t feel pressured or haggled. I brought my husband when he was ready for him new car too.

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star

take7 Sandy, UT

Used them to compare cars we were looking at and helped save us from buying a junk one at another dealership where the sales lady lied to us outright. Even gave a false car fax.

6 years ago