Autotrader Logo
star star star star star_border

5.3

Overall Score

Author: Kaitlyn Short

LAST UPDATED: March 5th, 2022

Autotrader.com seeks to be the ultimate solution in buying and selling certified, new and used cars. Serving customers for over 18 years, Autotrader.com provides a large selection of automobiles from both nationwide and local dealers and private sellers. The company also provides friendly customer service and tons of valuable research and comparison tools, reviews, and help with financing, warranties, and car insurance.

Autotrader.com provides car search and membership services completely free of charge. 

Keep reading for pros and cons, plus Autotrader reviews from real users. 

Top Ranked Companies

thumb_up

The Good

  • Great Features & Tools
  • Sell or Trade-In Your Car
  • Great Search & Profiles

Great Features & Tools

Autotrader.com features a comprehensive menu of features to help you select the right new or used car for your unique needs and style. There are hundreds of informative and up-to-date articles and reviews on a wide array of vehicles to choose from. Autotrader.com offers a diverse collection of features and benefits including:

  • Over 3 million vehicles in inventory from local and nationwide dealers and sellers
  • Buying and selling tips
  • Research and comparison tools with photos, videos, and reviews
  • Discounts and specials
  • Financing tools such as a Monthly Payment Calculator and Affordability Calculator
  • Warranty programs
  • Free car insurance quotes through Geico.com
  • Safety and vehicle history reports.

While we're on the subject of being prepared, AutoTrader has an array of tools and resources to better equip consumers to purchase or trade-in their car. Many of these tools are pretty standard in the auto website niche, but it always counts as a plus when several are included on the same site because it makes the car research and buying process so much more convenient.

Consumers on AutoTrader.com can find how much they would have to pay on an auto loan with the auto loan calculator. (AutoTrader also offers car loans, so the two go conveniently hand in hand). If you are trading in a car, the calculator shows you how much the traded car's value will impact loan payments. The calculator tool also allows consumers to find out what their car is worth to get an instant cash offer from AutoTrader's Trade-In Marketplace.

Sell or Trade-In Your Car

Placing an ad to sell a vehicle ranges from $25-$100. If you would like to receive expert help, VIP services are available from $159 to $289. These VIP packages include benefits such as pricing advice, privacy shields, solicitor blocking, and call screening, title transfer document services, and much more.

Trade-in offers are available by filling out a short questionnaire. An instant cash offer is generated immediately and sent to the requester's email and is valid for up to 72 hours. After a local dealer does an inspection on the vehicle, the instant cash offer can then be redeemed by cash or check or towards the purchase of another vehicle.

AutoTrader's Trade-In Marketplace allows car owners to trade their car in with what seems like 3 easy steps:

  • Step One: Tell AutoTrader about the car to be traded in and get a cash offer backed by AutoTrader.
  • Step Two: Visit a participating Trade-In Dealer and get a final offer.(Cash offer is based on the dealer's own car inspection report)
  • Step Three: Trade in Car or redeem final offer for cash.

This is compatible for the average car owner who has little working knowledge of cars or how to trade one in. Another likable aspect is that you're not locked into a deal or a price until the very end (i.e. Step three).

Car Search & Profiles

When car shoppers visit the AutoTrader.com website, the first option they get on the homepage is a "Find Cars for Sale" tool to research and compare new, certified and used cars by selecting their desired body type, mileage, price, and numerous other criteria. 

Be sure to select a price (and a price that is more than 4 figures) to get search results. Otherwise, no results will pull up.

Once on the results page, the site allows visitors to narrow down their search with more specific car specifications like mileage, minimum to maximum price range and minimum to maximum year range.

Each car or vehicle has a range of clear professional-quality pictures showcasing the car's front, rear, side, interior, and exterior.

Each car profile allows visitors to get a vehicle history by clicking the CARFAX icon positioned below the car photo. Just as useful are the car details provided upon clicking on the car profile. Some of the details include:

  • Exterior color/ interior color
  • Gasoline Mileage for City and Highway
  • Cylinder Type
  • Transmission type
  • Drive type (i.e. two-wheel drive)
  • Current mileage (i.e. 40,000 miles) for used cars

If the car is being sold by a car dealership, this page also provides the dealer's address and has an email sheet to email them directly. The "Find Your Car Your Way" page is really thorough, with additional specifications to choose from, including Basic Specifications:

  • Location
  • Condition
  • Price
  • Style
  • Year
  • Make
  • Model
  • Trim

Bonus Specifications:

  • Convenience/Comfort (3rd-row seats, backup camera, power locks, etc)
  • Entertainment/Technology (CD Player, Hands-free Blue Tooth, DVD player, Navigation, etc)
  • Luxury (Heated Seats, sunroof, leather seats, etc)
  • Miscellaneous (Disability-equipped, Trailer Hitch, etc)
  • Type of Seller (Dealers only, Private Sellers only, Trade-in Marketplace Dealers)

These specifications narrow the car search down significantly, filtering out what could become an overwhelming list of car listings to comb through. This means that the more the buyer knows about what they want, the better the search tool will work for them. It also prepares buyers before engaging dealers. They have all the information they need-from car history to CD player—to increase the chances they will get what they want for the price they want.

thumb_down

The Bad

  • Search Can Become Convoluted
  • Restrictions and Stipulations
  • No Information on Car Loans

Search Can Become Convoluted

One thing about the 3 million plus car listings is that you can easily get lost when searching for a car. Visitors should avoid searching for a car on the "Find Cars for Sale" tool on the Homepage, as it will pull up both new and used cars together, making your search convoluted. Instead, as previously suggested, select the Cars for Sale tab which will give you a thorough specification list.

Restrictions and Stipulations

Another thing: new traders need to understand that the Trade-in tool/feature is that it really isn't as simple as 1-2-3. Here's why:

  • Trade-In Marketplace is not available in all areas and not all vehicles are eligible for offers.
  • Instant Cash Offer is valid for 72 hours at participating dealerships.
  • Autotrader will not redeem Instant Cash Offers nor purchase customer's vehicle.
  • The offer is generated using an appraisal tool and it may not reflect the highest sale price or trade-in value for the vehicle.
  • Vehicle must pass a mandatory vehicle inspection by a participating dealer. If the inspection report differs from customer's description or online assessment of their vehicle's condition, the participating dealer may adjust the offer amount, which may mean decreasing the offer amount.
  • Participating dealers are not owned or operated by, nor are they affiliated with or acting on behalf of, Autotrader.
  • Autotrader holds no liability resulting from an adjustment of the offer or refusal to accept the vehicle by participating dealer(s).

There are even more details and restrictions, but the gist is that a better option would probably be a site that specializes in direct used car trade-ins with less small print stipulations, such as AuctionDirectUSA.com. The main issue that has popped up repeatedly in complaints is in regards to confusion concerning the 100 percent money back refund guarantee policy on advertisement fees if a vehicle does not sell within 90 days after placing an advertisement. As a result of these misunderstandings, Autotrader.com has discontinued the money back guarantees of this month. There are no official replacement offers at this time.

No Information on Car Loans

One other downside is that there appears to be no information on car loans on the site. When you click on loan on the navigation bar, you are lead to the website roadloans.com to apply for a car loan. Being able to get information on the various types of loans available and interest rates would be extremely valuable. One last recommendation is to upgrade user-friendliness. The iPhone app appears to have poor usability with only a 1.5 rating. The website also could run a speed diagnostic test. Modifying your search on the used car listings proves to be quite a chore. Very slow to upload.

gavel

The Bottom Line

One word describes AutoTrader.com: comprehensive. To date, the site has the biggest new and used car listing selection online. The plus is that there is so much to choose from and the minus is that it can be too much to choose from. The site answers this, however, with its "Find Your Car Your Way" page with a serious list of specifications to hone your search down to even minor details.

AutoTrader.com's list of research tools and information resources provide consumers with a full, qualified shopping experience.

Could the site use an upgrade to improve its apps and uploading time? Sure.

Has it proved that it fulfills its promise to its 14 million qualified buyers each month? Absolutely.

Overall, Autotrader.com appears to be an excellent comprehensive and trusted way to shop online.

View Best Car Finder Companies

Was this content helpful?
thumb_up Yes thumb_down No

Star Rating

info

4.2

star star star star star_border

66 Reviews

Review Breakdown

5 grade

48%

4 grade

38%

3 grade

5%

2 grade

3%

1 grade

6%

Sentiment Criteria

Value

star star star star star_border

Quality

star star star star star_border

Service

star star star star star_border

Trustworthiness

star star star star star_border
cancel
info
star star star star star_border

Brittney Mac Gregor Louisville, KY

I've been using autotrader since before there was even a website. Most people don't remember going to the gas station and buying an autotrader when they were either looking to sell or buy a car. I do! I have sold many cars, or rather helped my dad, (an independent car sale's man), sell many cars with autotrader. They always deliver excellent customers service. You use to call in and let them know what you wanted your ad to include and mail in a photo. Now it's super easy, just log in to their website, enter your details, pay the fee, and wait for the calls to pour in. A quick and easy way to sell your car. I have to take away one star however, as in these days there are so many ways to sell your car and get your name out there for free, so it's a little silly to continue to pay someone to do this. At the same time, there are many faithful collectors out there that hold on to autotrader as their means of searching for their dream car.

5 years ago

star star star star star_border

Mario Martin Montgomery, TX

During the beginning of the pandemic, it was difficult to find a auto dealer that was available to actually assist me with my vehicle search. I went to Autotrader and the anxiety of finding a good vehicle was reduced immediately and I was able to contact sellers and arrange on my own for vehicles I wanted to look at and/or purchase, not to mention Autotrader provided a broader listing of vehicles of my choice.

4 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star_border

upnorthwi Bellevue, WA

I feel Auto Trader is probably the best when searching for a particular vehicle, make, model, color, trim, package, cost, miles, location. I wanted a specific car. AutoTrader gives you a lot of vehicles to search from. I found that Auto trader is probably the best search platform that provided me with the most options. It is the only one that did find my vehicle I was searching for.

4 years ago Edited January 3, 2022

star star star star star_border

Audrey Mitchell Managua, MN

Autotrader is a great company to use when wanting to see the value of your car before selling it or trading it in. They have trustworthy price checks and give you decent quotes for your vehicles.

6 years ago

star star star star star_border

Jordon Patton Pflugerville, TX

Autotrader is my go to for car searches. I think they have the best repository for cars for sale in your area, both from dealers and private sellers. They have the best filters available to help you find what you're looking for.

5 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star_border

Natalie Brown Boulder, CO

I used Autotrader in finding the car that I bought. I thought the layout was nice and the tools they gave to sort out the numerous kinds of cars were nice too. I like how they included CarFax in the car reports! I didn't ever really feel like I was about to get scammed into buying a bad car.

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star_border

Shauna Horne American Fork, UT

We have used Autotrader in the past to help us research information about different models of vehicles. They have information about each model year of vehicles with user reviews. This allowed us to be able to get a good idea of the pros and cons of various models we were considering purchasing.

6 years ago

star star star star star_border

Mason Allen Provo, UT

Makes car browsing easy. Plenty of filter options to find the best match and lots of inventory if searching for a specific vehicle. Can be overrun with dealership ads, however.

5 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star_border

Lori Fletcher Saratoga Springs, UT

Great place to do research on cars because of how much information they provided about the cars verses others. We always came back to autotrader because they seemed to have every car there.

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star_border

Angelina Hamilton Gulfport, MS

I like how I can narrow down what I am looking for in a new car. If there are certain features I’m looking for I can narrow it down. I would not have found my current car if it wasn’t for this!

6 years ago

star star star star star_border

Yolanda Queer Shelley, ID

I like Autotrader's option to search by filtering how much you want to spend on car payments each month. It helps to find what is good for me.

5 years ago

star star star star star_border

Maryann Renteria (Mckrae) Riverton, UT

I used auto trader to find out what my car was worth and also to find a new car. I love how accurate and reliable it is.

6 years ago

star star star star star_border

Juan Beaver, PA

I posted my car on here before. I did get some inquiries but no one bought it. I do often use this site to find cars im interested in and it shows me cars in the area.

6 years ago

star star star star star_border

Katie Kearney Vienna, VA

My husband and I used Autotrader a lot when we were looking for a new truck for him. It was easy to navigate through and we had a lot of options to look at. It's a good site!

7 years ago

star star star star star_border

Rick Froid Park Ridge, IL

Autotrader is a great way to see what’s out there and get a great idea of the values of what your shopping for.

4 years ago

star star star star star_border

Morgan Tennant Rexburg, ID

AutoTrader was a reliable service, however I found that their website was often slow. Their service was great, though!

5 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star_border

Justin McMurtrey South Jordan, UT

Autotrader is great for researching vehicles and to see comparable prices. It has great options to also get qualified for loans.

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star_border

Cim Carver Cheyenne, WY

Whenever we have been in the market for a car, Autotrader is always one of the sites we use. Easy to use and great information.

6 years ago

star star star star star_border

De Ciantis Pittsburgh, PA

Easy to use with a fine guidance system to list your vehicle with all the pertinent information

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star_border

Customer Saratoga Springs, UT

Great research tool to use finding a car. Website was easy to use and plenty of inventory. Easy to narrow search.

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star_border

Kilee Wagner Eagle Mountain, UT

Was great in helping us find the best car possible and we ended up finding what we were looking for!

6 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star_border

Nell Damascus, MD

I like that you can find available cars near you. It is nice to have easy access

5 years ago

star star star star star_border

Kyle Provo, UT

Pretty good! I was impressed with the number of affordable cars I found on this site!

5 years ago

star star star star star_border

Kathie Bowman Lakeside, CA

I have used Autotrader to search for a car. The website was very easy to use and locate cars

7 years ago

check_circle

Review Source

star star star star star_border

Adam Dahl Herriman, UT

Does a great job giving me the ability to customize searches.

4 years ago